eley.org - Fruitland Twp's Think Tank
Home About Contact Header Bottom

Planning Commission Home Page

Map links for Master Plan review

Maps related to the revised Master Plan are posted on a web site for your convenience. These are public record documents and access permission has been granted by the host.

Web site link: Fruitland Township Map Resources
User name: fruitlandtwp
Password: 1210$CGFTWP

Why is this site password protected?


<<What is a Planned Unit Development?>>


Other useful references:
<Site plan review: what is the legal standard?>
<<How to participate in the zoning process>>


September 5, 2007

On September 5, after months of committee work under the leadership of planning commissioner, Carol Kooistra, the PC completed the Inland Lakes District and the North Duck Lake Overlay District. The new language was formally adopted into law by the Township Board on September 17.

In addition to stricter site development standards, the ordinances provide additional protections to preserve the environmental, aesthetic and hydrologic functions of the inland lakes, to protect the public health, safety and welfare of Fruitland citizens.

The PC publicly extended its appreciation to all who participated in the development of the new ordinances, especially township staff members, Don Sandel, Sally Garvey, and community representative, Chris Deur. Their efforts will help protect our precious lakes for generations to come.


July 18, 2007

On Wednesday, July 18, the Fruitland Township Planning Commission voted unanimously to adopt a new Master Plan and Future Land Use map for the township. The PC held its first hearing in January and, based on public input, went back to the drawing board to improve the text. Their efforts were commended by citizens at the July 18 public hearing.

The revised document, which is roughly 100 pages slimmer than its predecessor, presents a much clearer, more concise vision for the township, and includes specific goals, objectives and implementation guidance. Planners will now turn their attention to updating zoning ordinances and the existing zoning map to codify the Master Plan goals and objectives. <Read the Plan> <Future Land Use Map>

In addition to the Master Plan, the commission also held public hearing and adopted a new private street ordinance for streets accessing one parcel of land. The new ordinance, substantially reduces the financial and environmental impact for these applications. Previously, private streets accessing one parcel had to meet the same permitting and construction requirements as those accessing several parcels. The new standard will preserve trees, wildlife habitat and rural character.


April 4, 2007

On Wednesday, April 4, the Fruitland Township Planning Commission welcomed a new member, Mr. Brian Lernowich, to replace retiring commissioner, Sonny Gaertner. Mr. Lernowich will also serve at the commission's liaison to the Zoning Board of Appeals.

The commission conducted a public hearing on a proposed amendment to zoning ordinance Article III, General Provisions, Section 3.23, Non-conforming Buildings, Structures and Uses. The revised language gives additional latitude for the expansion or alteration of buildings that are non-conforming due to front or rear setback requirements. A provision was also added to subsection E1 Lots of Record that recognizes setbacks previously approved for subdivisions and condominiums. This "grandfather clause" enables owners of these properties to use the setback requirements originally approved when the subdivision or site condominium was created, even if subsequent changes are made to the setbacks in their zoning district. Before this provision was adopted, property owners in subdivisions or site condos had to go before the zoning board of appeals to request a setback variance.

The commission reopened public hearing on a private road application by Joel Kruszynski. Many neighbors cited concerns about encroaching development, traffic and environmental impact. After a lengthy discussion, Mr. Kruszynski agreed to work with the planning commission and zoning administrator, Don Sandel, to develop a new private road standard for single parcel access. This solution addresses neighbor's concerns and helps the planning commission resolve a challenge faced by many township property owners.

Currently, property owners who wish to build a house on a back lot without road frontage must construct a full-fledged private road -- an expensive, complex undertaking. The planning commission had planned to create a special standard for single parcel access and this application provides an excellent opportunity to complete the task. The result will significantly reduce environmental disturbance, i.e. tree cutting, drainage, etc. and help reduce the burden on property owners.

Another concern voiced by citizens was notification for public hearings. State law requires the township to publish a notice in the local newspaper (White Lake Beacon) and notify property owners within 300 feet of the affected parcel. This works well in urban areas, but not so well in rural communities, like Fruitland. One citizen suggested that the township put a sign on the affected property announcing the public hearing, so neighbors could see it when they drive by. The planning commission liked the idea and agreed to develop an enacting protocol.

The commission also approved a special land use permit for a blueberry farm on Orshal Road, south of McMillan. The board remanded the application to the planning commission, asking them to reconsider several conditional requirements included in their previous approval. The commission voted 4-2 to approve the application with an 1,800 square-foot accessory building located 150-feet back from the centerline of Orshal Road. The application now goes to the board of trustees for final approval.


March 7, 2007

On Wednesday, March 7, the Fruitland Township Planning Commission selected Main Street Planning Company as its "planner of record." The company will assist the PC and the zoning administrator in revising zoning ordinances, evaluating site plans and other technical duties.

The PC held public hearing on fourteen zoning ordinance amendments, including clarifications on how to measure side yard setbacks (to the eaves or foundation, whichever is closer) and what constitutes a hedge (a row of bushes, usually with their branches intermingled). The commission also held a public hearing on an application for a Private Street Construction Permit by Joel Kruszynski for a parcel located on Blank Road. The proposed road would allow access to two (2) proposed parcels to be created by land division. Several neighboring property owners expressed their opposition to the road, stating that it would change the character of the area and enable more development. Muskegon County Drain Commissioner, Martin Hulka, issued a letter citing drainage concerns about the proposed road and requiring additional technical information from the applicant. The PC voted to adjourn the application to the April meeting.

The commission also voted to recommend that the Board of Trustees extend the moratorium on developments of 5 or more parcels another 60 days. The additional time will be utilized to implement changes to the planned unit development and site condominium ordinances and the land use map, which are currently underway.

The productive session ended on a somber note when Clarence (Sonny) Gaertner announced that he would not seek reappointment to the planning commission after seven years of service; his term expires at the end of March. Mr. Gaertner also serves as the planning commission's liaison to the zoning board of appeals. He is a highly respected member of the commission and will be greatly missed. "Sonny is a man of few words," remarked one commissioner, "but when he speaks, everyone listens." Supervisor Boughton has 45 days to name his replacement.


February 7, 2007

On Wednesday, February 7, the Fruitland Township Planning Commission heard presentations from Main Street Planning and Williams & Works. The two planning firms are under consideration, along with LSL Planning, to assist the PC in revising zoning ordinances, evaluating site plans and other "planner of record" duties in the coming year. LSL will present its proposal at the March 7 meeting.

The PC also did a bit of "house keeping" and set public hearings on a number of minor zoning ordinance amendments, which have been accumulating over the past year. <read publication notice>

A special meeting was scheduled for Tuesday, February 13, to discuss proposed changes to the master plan and evaluate a proposed zoning ordinance to regulate large-scale residential development. The language has been prepared by LSL Planning and, if approved, will be scheduled for a March 7 public hearing.


December 6, 2006

The Wednesday, December 6, meeting of the Fruitland Township Planning Commission included final deliberation on a new development, two public hearings and a vote to recommend a 90-day moratorium on developments of five or more units/parcels.

Duck Creek Reserve LLC: the PC voted 5 - 2 to approve with conditions the site plan for Duck Creek Reserve, a 26 home development to be located on Duck Lake Road, just west of Simonelli. The applicant, Josh Fri, met Township ordinance and all site plan review standards. He also agreed to abide by additional conditions, including all recommendations of the Muskegon Conservation District (MCD), a no-cut buffer extending 100' from Duck Creek (except along the approved walking path; limited tree trimming for filtered view is also allowed under the supervision of MCD), no dock/deck constructed along Duck Creek can project more than 4' into the water, and no motorized vehicles are allowed on the pedestrian paths (except ADA-compliant devices). The PC did not approve the proposed bridge across Duck Creek, which accesses Township property, referring the matter to the Board.

The PC addressed citizen concerns regarding an excess inventory of unsold homes/parcels in the township, the development's consistency with the township's master plan, its harmony with the surrounding area, and the community's desire to preserve its rural residential character. These concerns were balanced against the specific requirements of the site plan review ordinance, which were met, and the developer's agreement to meet more restrictive environmental and construction standards. The law requires the PC to adhere to the zoning ordinance and, although master plan consistency and preservation of rural character can be considered as factors, they cannot be used exclusively to reject an application.

<More on site plan review: what is the legal standard?>

Blueberry Farm Special Land Use application: the PC voted 5 - 2 to approve with conditions Jeffrey Vanderbie's application to farm blueberries on a 30 acre parcel on Orshal Road, south of McMillan. The conditions were designed to provide additional protection for neighboring properties, including increasing the no-cut buffer along the south property border to 20', reducing the proposed accessory building from 2,400 sq. ft. to 1,800 sq. ft. and locating the building approximately 300' from the south property border. The applicant also agreed to provide copies of his state-mandated water and pesticide use reports to the township.

Deck construction Special Land Use: the PC voted unanimously to approve an application to construct two open decks at a South Shore Drive residence, located within the Shoreline Overlay District. The applicant met all zoning requirements.

Moratorium: the PC voted unanimously to recommend that the Township Board impose a 90-day moratorium on permit approvals for residential developments, land divisions, site condominium projects and similar developments resulting is five or more parcels, lots or plats. The intent is to review, update and adopt new regulations regarding residential developments that better reflect current needs and resident and property owner concerns, as well as to better promote public health, safety and welfare. Chair Eley will bring the recommendation to the Board at its December 18 meeting.

Your Source for News
New York Times
Resource List
News Area End